FoodForThought, I am absolute agree with you.
I don't like the SELECTION method, sometimes it can come against !
I enrolled my girls (4,8) to the CIS, the Administration officer was kind to send the application,and had positive attitude .
From what i have heard (i can assure you, i made my own research ..) the CIS is not lax at all. In matter of fact that is the main reason we are sending our daughters to this school.
Being a tough school does not assure at ALL, creative thinking, open mind to explore and to understand math problems (for example),it encourage your child in most cases to learn by hard,pass the exams and to fear from his teachers.
Personaly, i want my girls to discover the Science trend, and i belive that by illustration and realization the problems, my girls will understand (not just know by hard) all kind of Science problems and develop creative thinking.